Pakistan’s UN Envoy Criticizes India, but Uses Gaza News Photo to Do It

Posted by on Wednesday September 27, 2017 | Photojournalism

Pakistan's Maleeha Lodhi holds Heidi Levine's photo.

Pakistan's Maleeha Lodhi holds Heidi Levine's photo.

When Pakistan’s envoy to the UN accused India of attacking civilians in the disputed region of Kashmir, she waved a photo she claimed showed the bruised face of Kashmiri girl who had been struck by fire from a pellet gun used by the Indian army. There was one problem: The photo was taken in Gaza, not Kashmir.  Photojournalist Heidi Levine took the photo in 2014. It shows a Palestinian girl, Rawya Abu Joma’a, then 17, who had been injured in an Israeli airstrike.

“Normally a photojournalist would be honored to have their photograph shown before the UN General Assembly to help further show a global audience the horrific impact that war has on civilians,” Levine told PDN. “However, this is not the case and I feel not only shocked but ashamed to see such a mistake, as it compromises the dignity of Rawya.”

 

Pakistan UN envoy Maleeha Lodhi held up Levine’s photo at the UN general assembly on September 23, while arguing that India is conducting a “campaign of brutality inside Kashmir.” She was responding to claims by India’s external affairs minister Sushma Swaraj that Pakistan is “exporting terror.” Lodhi said the the photo shows “the face of Indian democracy in Kashmir.”

After reporters recognized the photo, Levine received a flood of emails and press requests. Levine says, “I was asked what I would like from Ms. Maleeha Lodhi in response to her mistake and as I mentioned earlier, my work was never meant ever to be about me, and I believe she owes an apology to Rawya.” She noted, “Rawya is not the face of India.”

Levine took the photo in 2014 at the Shifa Hospital in Gaza City, where abu Joma’a was recovering after an Israeli airstrike. The image was published in The New York Times, The Guardian and other publications around the world. Levine’s caption states that Rawya Abu Joma’a was wounded when two Israeli airstrikes struck her apartment building, killing her cousins and her sister. Abu Joma’a suffered multiple shrapnel wounds; the bones in one hand were crushed. (You can find the image and caption here.)

Levine says bloggers have sometimes used her work without her permission, but this was different. “I haven’t  seen my work misused without captions to this degree ever before and I have never heard of a photograph being misused like this at the UN or by other officials to this level. I hope I will never encounter seeing this again because it only undermines my efforts as a journalist and my commitment to uphold the highest standard of journalism I have spent my career committed to.”

Related articles:
After Staged Photo Debacle, World Press Changes Rules

Photojournalists on Ethics and Their Responsibilities

We Know Africa Is Not a Single Country, Newsweek Claims


COMMENTS

MORE POSTS

What We’re Liking: Women Photograph’s “Week in Pictures Gender Breakdown”

Posted by on Thursday October 19, 2017 | Business, Photojournalism

Women Photograph, the online database of women photographers around the world created by photographer Daniella Zalcman, is posting weekly Twitter threads to keep the gender disparity in photojournalism top of mind. The “Week in Pictures Gender Breakdown,” as the threads are titled, tally how many of the images used in the “week in pictures” features... More

Workshop Preview: Photographing Cars and Car Culture

Posted by on Monday October 2, 2017 | Photojournalism

Photographer Don Usner photographs lowriders, among other subjects related to his lifelong love for Northern New Mexico’s natural and cultural history. The cars, he says, “are incredible creations, beautiful art pieces.” But he adds that his work is “more about the people and seeing the cars as an expression of their cultural ethos. What’s exciting... More

PDN Video: Natalie Keyssar on Sexism in the Photo Industry

Posted by on Monday September 18, 2017 | Photojournalism

  Photojournalist Natalie Keyssar discusses how women (and photographers of color) are denied the same opportunities as white men in the photo industry, and why that needs to change. “It robs everyone, including white men, of the ability to understand other perspectives. In such a terribly polarized country as we’re in today, lack of empathy... More