April 3rd, 2013

Gun Rights Advocate Charged in Copyright Case Over Anti-Gay Attack Ads

©Kristina Hill

©Kristina Hill

A New York wedding photographer and a New Jersey gay couple who are jointly suing an anti-gay group for unauthorized use of an engagement photo (shown at right) are now going after a Colorado gun rights advocate, too.

The Denver Post reports that attorneys for the gay couple, Brian Edwards and Thomas Privitere, have filed papers in a Colorado federal court to add Dudley Brown and two gun groups–Rocky Mountain Gun Owners and the National Association for Gun Rights–to their lawsuit.

Edwards and Privitere, along with photographer Kristina Hill, sued a Virginia-based group called Public Advocate of the United States (PAUS) last year for unauthorized use of Hill’s engagement photo of the couple in political attack ads (shown below). The ads, distributed as campaign mailers in Colorado, were part of an effort to unseat candidates who had supported a push for same-sex unions in the state.

During the discovery process in the case against PAUS, the plaintiffs learned from e-mail records that Dudley Brown was behind the mailers, and that he worked with PAUS to distribute them, according to the Denver Post report. Brown is founder and executive director of Rocky Mountain Gun Owners, and executive VP of the National Association for Gun Rights. He allegedly used e-mail accounts associated with both organizations to correspond with PAUS about the campaign mailers.

gay-attack-adThe Denver Post report quotes one e-mail in which Dudley told PAUS: “What I propose is that [PAUS] pay for mailing. … My staff and I would do all the work, but we’d want [PAUS] to sign off, put its name on the dotted line, and pay for the mailings. I would counsel mailing slick and glossies, with the ‘two men kissing’ photo.”

The plaintiffs are charging infringement of Hill’s copyright and unlawful appropriation of the likenesses of Edwards and Privitere.

Related:
Anti-Gay Group Sued for Unauthorized Use of Photo in Attack Ads

Anti-Gay Group Pleads Fair Use, Free Speech in Infringement Case