Photographers Can Now Use FBI Anti-Piracy Seal. But Should They?

Anyone who has ever rented a movie has probably read the riot act on copyright infringement, which appears under a colorful FBI anti-piracy seal (shown at right) and says this:

“The unauthorized reproduction or distribution of a copyrighted work is illegal. 
Criminal copyright infringement, including infringement without monetary gain
is investigated by the FBI and is punishable by fines and federal imprisonment.”

Now that FBI seal and warning are available for use by any copyright holder–including photographers–who wants to use it to deter would-be infringers. Until earlier this week, it was legal only for members of five entertainment and software industry members to use the seal and warning. Those included big movie studios and video game producers.

In making the seal and warning available for use by all copyright holders, the FBI has eliminated fees and administrative requirements. Users can download the seal and post the warning free-of-charge, provided they follow the FBI rules for its use. One rule is that the seal and warning language must appear together. The seal also must be downloaded from this FBI Web page. The seal may not be animated, although it may be rendered in outline, grayscale, or black and white. And the seal and warning must not be used to imply the FBI’s endorsement of any photos, videos or other communications. (Complete rules and guidelines are available on the FBI’s Web site.)

It’s worth noting that just because a copyright holder posts the FBI’s anti-piracy notice doesn’t mean he or she can expect the FBI to investigate suspected infringements. Criminal infringement is defined in copyright law as primarily–though not exclusively–those infringements whereby someone undercuts the market for a movie or music recording by distributing bootleg copies before the official release.

For photographers, then, the benefit of the new FBI rule is that it offers an official law enforcement tool for warning people against infringement. And it does so by instilling an element of fear about dire consequences, like a sign on a chain link fence that says “Warning–premises protected by attack dogs,” even if there don’t happen to be any attack dogs actually present.

But that raises some question: Is the FBI warning overkill for photographers? Is the deterrent effect worth the risk of scaring off customers with a message that signals a certain level of unfriendliness? Or has copyright infringement become such a problem that more dire warnings are in order?

Tags: ,

16 Responses to “Photographers Can Now Use FBI Anti-Piracy Seal. But Should They?”

  1. Craig Says:

    I’m not sure the value of this, do you put it on your website? Do you watermark every image with it?

    And considering the general ineffectiveness of the FBI in this, isn’t it sort of a ineffectual?
    I see this image probably 100 or more times a year while watching movies, it’s so common that I pretty much don’t really “see it” for seeing it.

    When this logo then gets used, what thousands or hundreds of thousands or million times more for people that will never exercise their copyright rights, won’t that just dilute it further?

  2. Alex Says:

    Until you have photos stollen, that “you” spent money and time to create for you or a client, you will not understand why this matters so much.

  3. Chicken Soup for Photographers- Couldn’t Hurt « Says:

    [...] to an article on PDN.com, photographers can use the “FBI Copyright Warning”. You know the one that appears [...]

  4. Photographers Can Now Use FBI Anti-Piracy Seal. But Should They? | The Click Says:

    [...] Link: PDN Pulse » Blog Archive » Photographers Can Now Use FBI Anti-Piracy Seal. But Should They? In making the seal and warning available for use by all copyright holders, the FBI has eliminated fees and administrative requirements. Users can download the seal and post the warning free-of-charge, provided they follow the FBI rules for its use August 18, 2012 Categories: Copyright Leave a comment 0 [...]

  5. Mark Says:

    For photographers who are doing commissioned, non commercial client work this is not a deterrent to the client. People will ignore it and copy whatever they want. Most of the time (in a non-commercial way) nobody really cares about your image being stolen except you. If you don’t want someone to download it, screen capture it, etc… don’t make it available online or on disc. That’s the only way to be sure. Today, of course, that is not very practical. So get paid first because someone will copy your image.

  6. Photographers Can Now Use the FBI’s Anti-Piracy Seal to Scare Away Thieves Says:

    [...] to make people think twice about using your copyrighted photographs without permission.(via FBI via PDN)var switchTo5x=false;stLight.options({publisher:'52b76d3d-a3cc-420e-9ad5-5754a0610115'});  [...]

  7. Photographers Can Now Use the FBI Anti-Piracy Seal to Scare Away Thieves « JTJonesphotos Says:

    [...] (via FBI via PDN) Share this: Pin ItMoreEmailPrintDiggShare on TumblrLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. [...]

  8. The Legend of Zelda: Hyrule Historia, contains an unparalleled collection of historical information on The Legend of Zelda franchise. This book has never-before-seen concept art, the full history of Hyrule, the official chronology of the games, and much m Says:

    Hello, i think that i saw you visited my web site thus i came to go back the favor?.I’m trying to to find things to enhance my website!I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas!!

  9. Tom Says:

    @Legend of Zelda: best comment ever on a piece about copyright infringement!

  10. MyNameHere Says:

    This will be less effective than the Federal Do No Call List. How’s that working for you?

    The majority of the people infringing my images know what they are doing and assume (rightfully) that they will not be caught, or will get a DMCA Take Down slap on the wrists . . .

  11. [live auction sites] [online auction websites] [auction websites] [penny auction scam] [cheap auction sites] [auction sites] [penny auction sites] [free auction sites] [auction website] [online auctions sites] [live auctions] [best auction site] [internet Says:

    Hello, Neat post. There is a problem with your site in web explorer, might test this? IE nonetheless is the market leader and a huge section of people will leave out your fantastic writing due to this problem.

  12. Capturesuqe Says:

    Quite interesting. At least they opened it up to let us choose to use it or not.

  13. Photographers Can Now Use The Giant, Ugly FBI Anti-Piracy Seal · NEWS on the Dreamspace Says:

    [...] now you have another tool. As PDN Pulse pointed out, the FBI has loosened its rules on who can use their anti-piracy warning, so now all US copyright [...]

  14. Efrain Says:

    Posting the notice will also take away the”innocent infringer” defense to any copyright infringer.

  15. [earn extra money online] [earn commission online] [earn income online free] [how to make earn money online] [making money with online marketing] [making money online from home] [make money online money] [make money online online] [about making money onli Says:

    Wow, amazing weblog layout! How lengthy have you ever been blogging for? you made running a blog glance easy. The entire look of your web site is great, let alone the content material!

  16. togs can use the FBI seal to protect your work « Fuzzypictures's Weblog Says:

    [...] (via FBI via PDN)(petapixel} [...]