Corbis Inks Print-on-Demand Consumer Deal

Corbis and warehouse retailer Costco have announced a deal to offer print-on-demand photographs, posters, and giclée canvas prints through nearly 600 Costco stores around the world. Corbis has made more than 20,000 travel, nature, landscape and other images available for the program, which has alarmed some of its contributors.

Costco and Corbis expect customers to purchase images as decor for homes and small businesses, including restaurants and hotels.

Corbis described the deal as a “large new market opportunity for contributors” because Costco has “tens of millions of customers.” Spokesman Dan Perlet says Corbis has licensed images for posters in the past, but the Costco deal is the agency’s first print-on-demand deal.

Prices range from $1.49 for 8×10 prints to $8.99 for a 20×30 poster print, and $79.99 for a 24×32 giclée canvas print to $99.99 for a 16×48 panoramic giclée canvas print.

Perlet says he’s barred from disclosing revenue sharing details. But he says  the terms are “more advantageous for Corbis and its contributors compared to traditional up-front merchandising agreements in the past.” Even so, he warns that small payments from $1.49 sales will be “potentially unsettling” to photographers who soon see those payments on sales reports.

Corbis contributors have expressed some concerns about the deal, according to Shannon Fagan, a Corbis contributor who also chairs the ASMP Stock License Committee. One concern is that the inexpensive Costco prints could undercut Corbis contributors who sell fine art prints on their own, Fagan says.

Another concern, he adds, is that Costco customers may not understand intellectual property–and the limits of the rights they get when they buy a print from Costco. For instance, some customers might scan the images and use them on their small business web sites, Fagan says.

Corbis and Costco give the impression that customers can do that–and more–with the prints they buy.

For instance, Costco photo manager Glen Hutchinson says in a joint press release from Corbis and Costco: “Through our arrangement with Corbis, we provide our members [customers] with the security that they have the copyright permission to use the images as they like, and that the images are all properly licensed for their use – even for resale.”

But an FAQ that Corbis issued to quell the fears of photographers contradicts that. “Costco members do not get access to the digital file of the image, and can only purchase physical product from Costco. Any other uses require a license from Corbis,” the agency says in the FAQ.

Perlet says of the discrepancy that the press release “is not as clear as it should be.” He explains, “the word ‘image’ is used generically to mean ‘merchandise.’ It should say, ‘We provide our members with the security that they have copyright permission to print the merchandise and that the merchandise can be for resale.'”

He goes on to say that Costco customers cannot scan the images for other uses, such as web sites, and adds, “Our piracy team will be looking for instances like that.”

Meanwhile, Fagan has cautiously endorsed the Corbis/Costco deal, at least in principle. “Photographers have to move into the consumer space to survive, and this deal falls into that micropayment model: a little money from a lot of people,” he says. He doesn’t think, however, that the Costco deal will add up to a lot of money for most photographers. “But I could be wrong,” he adds.

12 Responses to “Corbis Inks Print-on-Demand Consumer Deal”

  1. Paul Eekhoff Says:

    Providing I understand this agreement correctly, it appears as though a COSTCO customer can purchase my image and then sell that image again……please tell me this is not true. What right does a COSTCO customer have to resell my image for a profit when I may only receive a couple of bucks from CORBIS!! Why am I transferring my copyright to a COSTCO customer? This has gone too far and has exceeded fair use. I do not shoot for CORBIS but
    I empathize for those who do. I am fully aware of the new dynamics of online commerce and the concept of “free” but this strips photographers of the last remaining tidbits of power and dignity they may believe
    they have!

  2. Paul Eekhoff Says:

    If the customer can purchase an 8×10 print for $1.49, then what is Corbis selling the image for? Hey, I have an idea….I’m going to buy up the COSTCO collection of images for $1.49 and resell them as custom art prints for
    $100.00 bucks….who’s in? any CORBIS shooters wanting to make some cash back on their images?

  3. Dave Ewers Says:

    This is what we all get for embracing micro-stock. I can gaurantee that some of these photographs will be used in ads.

  4. Shannon Fagan Says:

    ASMP’s Stock Imaging License Committee has been discussing the Corbis initiative on the ASMPstock yahoo groups forum. The Corbis FAQ is posted there and addresses the issues raised here in more detail.

    No membership in ASMP is required to join the forum. We invite interested persons to participate in the discussion:

    Shannon Fagan
    Chair, ASMP Stock Imaging License Committee

  5. stock image Says:

    interesting deal and i noticed the photo stands at costco selling prints in the store one of the last times i was there (not corbis photos, i dont believe). i also wonder what corbis contributors will think about the small payments like you wrote about.

    But I snickered at corbis and costco having to clarify the rights and then this comment regarding scanned images, ““Our piracy team will be looking for instances like that.” Tough to find and fight someone who has bought a 1.49 image and scanned it to use on their website.

  6. David Sanger Says:

    @Paul Actually whenever you buy a print or a book or a mug or a poster or a t-shirt you can resell it.

    It is even written into the Copyright Act, §109 , that the owner can sell “without the authority of the copyright owner” . That’s how merchandising works, and used book stores.

    They cannot, however, make any copy.

  7. dave Says:

    David Sanger wrote:
    “Actually whenever you buy a print or a book or a mug or a poster or a t-shirt you can resell it.”

    With all due respect, with the examples that you cite, aren’t you referencing the end usage, not the original image?

  8. Paul Eekhoff Says:

    all depends on how “any copy” becomes defined in the future.

  9. android Says:

    im kinda tired and tired of the battery on my android going down so fast, seriously annoys the crap out of me, see what happens, find a good site and BAM my battery is dead, so yeah, i luckily had enough battery to read this and post the comment haha, i have no life. yay me!

  10. Colalex Gallery » Archive » Photo Magazine Says:

    […] Photo Magazine […]

  11. Real Photographer Says:

    VERY glad that when my agency hooked up with Corbis that I took ALL my images back.

  12. peter berberian Says:

    I would be worried about what these prints will even look like. Are they going to be made on site at each Costco? Adorama can’t even make a good print and they are kind of in the photo business. I can only imagine how awful a Costco print will be.