A state court judge in Maryland has thrown out charges against a motorist for videotaping a police officer during a traffic stop, according to The Baltimore Sun. The judge said that as public officials, police have no reasonable expectation of privacy while carrying out their duty.

Motorcyclist Anthony Graber had been charged with violating Maryland’s wiretapping laws last spring after he used a helmet-mounted camera to tape his encounter with a state patrolman. Graber had the camera running as he sped along I-95, and kept it rolling as a plainclothes police officer eventually caught up with him and ordered him off the motorcycle at gunpoint. The police officer didn’t know he was being taped.

Graber was arrested for violating wiretap laws shortly after he posted the video of the incident on YouTube. When he was arrested, police raided his house and seized his cameras and computer gear.

Wiretapping laws are intended to protect privacy by preventing anyone from eavesdropping on or recording conversations without the knowledge of one or both parties. In many states, including Maryland, both parties must be aware that their conversation is being taped. But the judge in the Graber case said that a police stop is not a private conversation, so it isn’t covered by the state’s wiretapping laws.

The outcome of the Graber case has been watched closely by journalists and First Amendment advocates as a test of the power of police to prevent scrutiny of their activities. Police have tried to use wiretapping laws in several other jurisdictions, although the Graber ruling doesn’t apply outside Maryland.

Tags:

COMMENTS

MORE POSTS

Magnum Foundation Announces 2016 Emergency Fund Grants

Posted by on Wednesday March 23, 2016 | Uncategorized

Eighteen photographers from around the world have been awarded the 2016 Magnum Foundation Emergency Fund, a grant that helps independent photographers produce in-depth and creative stories on underreported issues. Grantees were selected by an independent editorial committee from a pool of 140 photographers nominated by 26 international editors, curators, and educators. The grantees are: Poulomi Basu,... More

Edward Burtynsky Establishes Photo Book Grant with Prize Money

Posted by on Friday March 11, 2016 | Uncategorized

Photographer Edward Burtynsky announced this week that he will use a CAD 25,000 ($18,892) award he received to establish a photo book publishing grant for Canadian emerging photographers. The money will support one CAD 5,000 ($3,778) grant per year for the next five years. Burtynsky had received the cash prize from The Canada Council for... More